Is the Balanced Scorecard Approach better than other systems of Managing Performance?

Is the Balanced Scorecard Approach better than other systems of Managing Performance?

To those who have no knowledge of the balanced scorecard approach to performance management I encourage you to read my previous articles on the same subject. There has been debate in both the corporate world and academic circles on whether the balanced scorecard approach is better than other systems of managing performance. My answer to this question is yes and it’s based on several years of experience using the balanced scorecard approach both locally and regionally.

First, I must make it very clear that the Balanced Scorecard will yield the desired results provided certain conditions exist within the implementing organisation. Top among these conditions is that there must be unwavering support from both the Board of Directors and top executives. The second factor is that top management must be willing to use the balanced scorecard approach as a management tool and make it part of the culture of the organisation. Just like budgeting, the balanced scorecard must be used as one of the many tools in the management tool kit. The third factor is that the balanced scorecard must be used to recognise those adding more value to the organisation and they must be rewarded accordingly.[inlinetweet prefix=”” tweeter=”” suffix=””] Without recognising those achieving the desired results over and above the call of duty the balanced scorecard will fail.[/inlinetweet]

When the above conditions have been met the balanced scorecard approach will yield good results for your organisation provided its implemented properly. The major reason why some scorecard initiatives fail is that many organisations fail to take advantage of one of the key advantages of the balanced scorecard which is the ability to bring out measurable goals. There has been confusion for decades on how to define performance. While others would want to take performance as the process used in achieving results, the more recent and more effective definition is the one that looks at performance as an output or result. Due to the confusion surrounding the definition of performance some organisations have focused on measuring behaviour or personality and calling that performance. The danger with such an approach is that both dimensions are very subjective and are often used by managers to settle scores with employees. This results in employees resenting performance management and more specifically performance appraisals.

One factor that is sure to derail the success of any performance management system is how performance is measured. In the majority of cases we have tended to focus on things that are not measurable and calling these performance. People often refer to action plans as goals when in fact action plans are activities undertaken in order to achieve a goal. With this wrong categorisation of goals some organisations end up rewarding people for engaging in activities that have no direct impact on the outcome. I already see this confusion in the government where there are very few tangible goals set but an avalanche of action plans with no direct link to any specific goal. The following example will help you understand why it’s necessary to distinguish between a goal and an action plan. There was a beekeeper with two sections: section A and section B. In both sections the management there were mandated to come up with the best way to measure the performance of the bees and reward them accordingly. In section A the bees were measured on the number of flowers visited and in section B on the amount of nectar collected. After a few months after the introduction of the of the system section B was far ahead in terms of producing honey than section A. In section A the bees were moving from one flower to the other in order to reach the target of visiting as many floors as possible. In the process of visiting as many flowers as possible they lost sight of the overriding goals of producing more honey for exports. I am sure if bees in section A were given a clear goal they would have produced a different result. Look at your organisation: how many people are visiting flowers and not collecting nectar because of the way goals are set and how the rewards are structured. The government might run the risk of visiting too many flowers without actually collecting the nectar because of how their goals have been structured.

Most of the items called goals are not goals but action plans. The majority of what are termed goals or objectives are not measureable at all. They suffer from the following problems: they are actions and not results, they are about planning to plan, they are made up of high sounding words such as: accountable, aligned, capacity, collaborative, commitment, ensure, promote, stabilise, enhanced, maintain, optimise, robust, sustainable etc. These are the words you find in documents that are not written in results language and they yield very little results if any at all. Most strategy documents suffer from this problem. When something is said to be measurable you must be able to: to count it, you must be able to observe it-to see it, hear it, touch it, detect it objectively and consistently. In order to observe something you must be able to describe it and separate it from other things so that you can recognise it.

How do you then structure the goals so that you can start collecting nectar? Goals must be structured in the following ways. Within the balanced scorecard approach a goal is made up of a: goal, measure, baseline target, stretch target and reporting frequency. The goal must always start with an action verb such as grow revenue, build a strong employer brand, reduce costs, create new jobs, increase capacity utilisation etc. Your measures are the indicators of performance. On the goal of growing revenue the measure will be “percentage growth in revenue”, on the goal of building a strong employer brand you could have the following measures; employee satisfaction index, percentage retention of competent staff, % of offer letters accepted by new recruits and % of new recruits who resign before completing probation . A target within the balanced scorecard framework is the desired level of performance. You should never have a date as the desired level of performance. There are two types of targets; the baseline target which represents the minimum performance required. The baseline target is that performance for which an employee is earning their basic salary and other fixed benefits. If they fail to achieve the baseline target even disciplinary action must be instituted. The other target is the stretch target which represents performance that deserves recognition. Within the balanced scorecard framework we have what is called the reporting frequency. This indicates the period within which the target will be assessed or tracked. This can be daily, weekly, monthly, quarterly or yearly. After coming up with the goals it is advisable that you start working on activities or action plans that will enable you to achieve the goals. Employees must remember that they will not be rewarded for auctioning action plans but for achieving the agreed goals and targets.

Setting goals in this format ensures that you do not pay people for “corridor mileage” or “visiting flowers”. I have no doubt that performance management failures are a failure of leadership. The lack of performance culture in any organisation should be placed squarely on the CEO of the organisation.

Memory Nguwi. Memory Nguwi is an Occupational Psychologist, Data Scientist, Speaker, & Managing Consultant- Industrial Psychology Consultants (Pvt) Ltd a management and human resources consulting firm. He is the president of the Zimbabwe Psychology Association. He hosts a radio program HR Perspective every Thursday at 1900hrs on Capitalk 100.4FM. https://www.linkedin.com/in/memorynguwi/ Phone 481946-48/481950/2900276/2900966 or cell number 077 2356 361 or email: mnguwi@ipcconsultants.com  or visit our website at www.ipcconsultants.com

426 Responses

  1. casino video slots winner,
    infer tonoslots
    slotomania free slots no download

  2. writing paper
    dissertation research
    writing a dissertation literature review

  3. average dissertation length
    uga dissertation
    dissertation writing grants

  4. Joetestsl says:

    definition of dissertation
    example of dissertation
    dissertation editing help

  5. thesis and dissertation writing
    dissertation help uk
    doctoral dissertation writing assistance

  6. Avivastsl says:

    write a dissertation abstract
    writing dissertations
    dissertation writing service

  7. doctoral dissertation help your
    dissertation help online
    do my dissertation

  8. dissertation writing fellowships
    help tutor
    all but dissertation

  9. doctoral dissertation
    dissertation editing
    average dissertation length

  10. dissertation online help
    dissertation acknowledgement sample
    phd dissertation writing help

  11. Sallistsl says:

    uk dissertation writing
    proposal and dissertation help plan
    dissertation research

  12. Tandistsl says:

    best casino welcome bonus
    online casinos
    united states online casino

  13. format for writing dissertation proposals
    what is a dissertation
    writing dissertation methodology

  14. Tandistsl says:

    best online casinos for real money
    united states online casino
    online casino welcome bonus

  15. dissertation cover page
    art dissertation help
    dissertation proposal template

  16. writing a phd dissertation
    dissertation methodology
    how to cite a dissertation

  17. cherry jackpot casino
    best online bingo
    real online casino

  18. how to write a dissertation proposal
    help with dissertation writing
    dissertation handbook

  19. casino play for real money
    welcome bonus casino
    best mobile casino

  20. Audrestsl says:

    dissertation proposal writing services
    dissertation writing service
    psychology dissertation

  21. casino bonus online
    free slots for mac
    best casino online

  22. uk dissertation writing
    dissertation paper writing service
    dissertation proposal template

  23. Dixiestsl says:

    online casino game real money
    real money casino
    casino sites

  24. real money online casinos
    real money casino no deposit
    free casinos bonus

  25. best casino sites
    free sign up bonus no deposit casino
    online casinos that pay real money

  26. Pearlstsl says:

    no deposit welcome bonus casino
    best mobile casinos
    best casinos online

  27. real money online casinos
    gambling casino online bonus
    mobile casino

  28. casino bonus online
    no deposit casino games
    casino games that pay real money

  29. casino free spins
    online mobile casino
    free no deposit

  30. mobile casinos
    online casino deposit bonus
    online casino free money

  31. best free vpn for ios
    best lifetime vpn
    free vpn extension

  32. online blackjack for real money
    online casino bonuses
    online casino no deposit

  33. casino play for real money
    casino online usa
    free bonus no deposit

  34. free trial vpn
    which free vpn is best?
    best vpn for gaming reddit

  35. casino welcome bonus no deposit
    free sign up bonus online casino
    casino no deposit

  36. windscribe vpn reviews
    free mexico vpn
    vpn router

  37. Fanyastsl says:

    play blackjack online money
    gambling casino online bonus
    casino no deposit bonus

  38. where to buy a vpn
    vpn browser free
    best vpn proxy betternet

  39. vpn for pc windows 10 free
    best vpn for the money
    best vpn to change location

  40. best vpn for school
    incognito vpn
    sonicwall vpn client

  41. online casino best bonus
    real money casino games
    best online casinos for us players

  42. Gladistsl says:

    gay dating hookup
    gay black dating site
    best gay dating apps for men over 40

  43. Joannstsl says:

    personals free
    singles near me free
    best dating service

  44. young gay boys looking for daddies dating
    the best gay christian dating app
    gay catholic dating

  45. gay dating simulator tumblr
    adam4adamn gay dating
    international gay dating website

  46. which is best online dating site
    online chatting sites
    japanese chubby

  47. BLorodahv says:

    pharmacie de garde saint malo pharmacie de garde colmar pharmacie chu angers numero , therapie comportementale et cognitive insomnie therapies biologiques , pharmacie de garde marseille terrasse du port pharmacie auchan dieppe horaires therapies breves et hypnose Pregabalina farmacia sin receta, Comprar Pregabalina 300 mg genГ©rico [url=https://www.jotform.com/build/222351919120044#]Pregabalina barato en la farmacia[/url] Pregabalina farmacia sin receta Pregabalina precio sin receta. pharmacie aix en provence geant casino therapie comportementale et cognitive beauvais Amoxil barato en la farmacia, Comprar Amoxil envГ­o libre [url=https://www.jotform.com/build/222346812317048#]Comprar Amoxil envГ­o libre[/url] Amoxil precio Venezuela Amoxil farmacia sin receta. pharmacie nansouty bordeaux horaires pharmacie autour de moi ouverte , pharmacie auchan petite foret ouverture pharmacie amiens Cherche Wynzora moins cher, Wynzora sans ordonnance Belgique [url=https://www.jotform.com/build/222361883457058#]Wynzora prix sans ordonnance[/url] Wynzora prix sans ordonnance Wynzora sans ordonnance prix. therapie de couple saint etienne medicaments flatulences .

  48. online dating for singles
    dating sinulator online
    free single dating online

  49. lesbian cowgirls
    facebook dating site
    free web date site

  50. Gladistsl says:

    college gay dating site
    dating guys when 18 gay
    north leeds gay dating

  51. dating site free
    plenty fish date site
    adult singles dating site

  52. gay dating sit
    michael dinsmore gay dating
    gay white men dating black men

  53. dating sites our time
    free singles
    dating sites

  54. gay farmers dating sites
    gay conservative dating app
    gay male 65 + dating

  55. Lettistsl says:

    matchmaking services
    dating sites free near me
    free online dating service

  56. Amatastsl says:

    best online casino
    online casino welcome bonus
    gambling casino online bonus

  57. SeltRable says:

    Internet pharmacies generally offer you a wide range of payment methods online cialis

  58. credgefn says:

    pharmacie ouverte figeac pharmacie lafayette grimaldi nice pharmacie leader argenteuil , therapies breves hypnose emdr imo (valerie marie bry) pharmacie de garde poitiers , pharmacie jean paul coste aix en provence pharmacie ouverte narbonne pharmacie leclerc oudairies roche yon pharmacie avignon les clayes sous bois pharmacie touati argenteuil pharmacie de garde aujourd’hui pas de calais .
    pharmacie vallet bourges pharmacie bailly livraison pharmacie amiens fac , pharmacie bourges cap nord pharmacie de garde aujourd’hui besancon . pharmacie lafayette tarbes therapies epilepsy therapie de couple rouen act therapie acceptation engagement . pharmacie de garde aujourd’hui tahiti medicaments bouffees de chaleur pharmacie avignon ouverte , pharmacie de garde aujourd’hui yvelines traitement gastro , targeted therapies pharmacie orthopedie bordeaux therapie comportementale et cognitive duree Finax livraison express Belgique, Vente Finax bon marchГ© Finax livraison express Belgique, Vente Finasteride bon marchГ© Finax livraison express Belgique Finax 1mg pas cher. therapies breves psychanalyse pharmacie de garde marseille castellas therapies basees sur la mentalisation pharmacie ouverte la plus proche pharmacie victor hugo 92100 boulogne-billancourt , pharmacie lafayette givors pharmacie lafayette jean jaures toulouse . pharmacie avignon les clayes sous bois pharmacie avignon auchan pharmacie de garde zuydcoote

  59. Lettistsl says:

    dating sites free chatting
    online site
    christian dating

  60. asain gay chat phone lines
    free gay/bi-sex chat sites
    wed chat gay free

  61. Deeynstsl says:

    gay male incest chat
    zoom cams gay sex chat
    older gay video chat

  62. gay chat lines in atlanta
    gay sex chat no registration
    gay video chat for windows 8

  63. floonop says:

    In animal reproduction studies, no adverse developmental effects were observed with oral administration of tadalafil to pregnant rats or mice during organogenesis at exposures up to 11 times the maximum recommended human dose MRHD of 20 mg day see Data cialis generic name

  64. cheap venlafaxine 75 mg buy effexor online cheap purchase effexor without prescription

  65. generic effexor purchase effexor pills order venlafaxine 150mg generic

  66. oral pregabalin order generic lyrica 75 mg order pregabalin 150mg generic

  67. Alventiz says:

    Thanks a lot. A lot of material.
    online coursework online essay writers wanted

  68. ring central gay chat rooms
    free gay web cam chat rooms
    gay chat rooms phoenix

  69. ivermectin 0.08 oral solution ivermectin rx buy stromectol pills

  70. ivermectin 0.1 topical ivermectin cost buy ivermectin canada

  71. gay phone chat line free trial
    most popular video gay chat
    gay perv chat group

  72. order sildenafil for sale cenforce cheap cenforce pill

  73. Hildestsl says:

    gay porn video chat
    popular gay chat 360
    gay sex chat roulette

  74. BF Codzienne Jackpoty: każdego dnia kasyno wybiera określoną liczbę jackpotów, w których można liczyć na częstsze wygrane.  Jedną z głównych korzyści płynących z gry w wirtualnych kasynach są bonusy i promocje. Niemal wszystkie kasyna oferują nagrody w takiej czy innej formie, od darmowych spinów w kasynach online po bonusy powitalne, bonusy do gier, cashback i różne korzyści dla stałych klientów. Oprócz bonusów bez depozytu, kasyna online witają nowych klientów bonusami z darmowymi spinami. Ten rodzaj bonusu kasynowy może być oferowany jako opcja bez depozytu, opcja darmowych obrotów bez depozytu lub jako część bonusu powitalnego. Nowa licencja Europejskie kasyno z dużym wyborem kryptowalut: BTC, ETH, BCH, LTC, DOGE, USDT. + 100% bonus od pierwszego depozytu i 100 darmowych spinów jako prezent! https://blackgirlhealing.org/community/profile/lavina911447639/ Dołącz do naszego newslettera i skorzystaj z szeregu korzyści. To m.in powiadomienia o najgorętszych bonusach, a nawet dostęp do dedykowanych promocji dla zapisanych osób. Znajdź dla siebie dobre kasyno. Szczegółowe wyjaśnienie zasad i możliwości znajdziesz tutaj. Wiadomości lokalne No, no – od 2000 r. jest naczelnikiem! Czyli, jak dobrze liczę została nim w wieku 25 lat. To dopiero geniusz polskiej administracji samorządowej. A kiedy zrobiła studia, skoro w międzyczasie pracowała w biurze rady miasta i w obsłudze zarządu? Po prostu specjalista grubą nicią szyty. Zły wybór Panie Mańkowski (21 opinii) Jaką jeszcze ;\ppdnóżkową: rolę spełnia Pan z fotografii… specjalista d s specjalnych (przynieś

  75. gay chat rooms, san diego
    gay chat roulette adult
    free live gay webcam chat rooms

  76. InaplyGap says:

    Any idea what it could be. safest place to buy clomid in the uk Finally 72 patients were allocated to group 1 CC plus rFSH group and 72 patients to group 2 CC plus HMG group figure1.

  77. Heskisons says:

    Tavernier N, Fumery M, Peyrin-Biroulet L, Colombel JF, Gower-Rousseau C. order clomid from india online

  78. random chat gay
    gay fl chat
    older gay chat

  79. Alvinhub says:

    Truly plenty of good information.
    online essay writing service review https://service-essay.com/ i need help writing a thesis statement

  80. Kudos. Excellent stuff.
    canada online pharmacies us pharmacy no prior prescription online pharmacy busted

  81. You actually said this very well.
    pharmacies canada pharma limited llc best online pharmacy stores

  82. Alvinhub says:

    Point effectively taken!!
    music for writing essays write that essay letter writing help online

  83. Alvinhub says:

    Superb content. Cheers.
    how to cite a website in an essay https://englishessayhelp.com/ reliable essay writing service

  84. Alvinhub says:

    Thanks, An abundance of knowledge.
    pay to write my essay cheap custom essays online best online resume writing services

  85. 1st avenue chat gay
    chat gay con camra
    gay chat cam rabdom

  86. Effectively expressed genuinely! .
    canada discount drug canada prescriptions drugs canadian pharmacies online

  87. Lovely data, With thanks.
    get prescription online canada rx online pharmacy without prescription

  88. Alvinhub says:

    You actually stated that superbly.
    how to write a why college essay essay typer write my essay service

  89. Alvinhub says:

    Regards, I value this.
    how to write a great narrative essay https://essayssolution.com/ me as a writer essay

  90. Alvinhub says:

    Truly tons of terrific tips.
    how to write an autobiographical essay college essay harvard best online resume writing services

  91. Nicely put, Thank you.
    price pro pharmacy canada canadian pharmacies that ship to us northwest pharmacy/com

  92. Kudos, I value it.
    canadian drugs without prescription canadian pharmacy without prescription viagra canada

  93. Mindystsl says:

    black gay men phone chat
    chat gay con camra
    100% free gay chat line

  94. Alvinhub says:

    Amazing write ups. Many thanks.
    should college athletes be paid persuasive essay argumentative essay topics essay writing service australia

  95. Alvinhub says:

    Thanks. Lots of advice.
    cheap essay services essay writer custom writing discount code

  96. Alvinhub says:

    With thanks. I value it.
    best college application essay argumentative essay topics trusted essay writing service

  97. Kudos. Plenty of write ups!
    online pharmacies legitimate cheap medications pharmacy online shopping

  98. You actually said this perfectly.
    canadian pharmacies without an rx mexican online pharmacies meds online without doctor prescription

  99. Alvinhub says:

    Nicely put, Regards!
    how to write an introduction to a persuasive essay essay rewriter blog writing services

  100. Alvinhub says:

    You said this effectively.
    college essays for sale https://topswritingservices.com/ website analysis essay

  101. Lovely facts, Appreciate it.
    pain meds online without doctor prescription canada drugs pharmacy pharmacy online cheap

  102. You actually expressed this wonderfully!
    pharmacy intern drugstore online canada pharmacies online

  103. Alvinhub says:

    Regards! Lots of postings.
    writing custom essays how to write an argument essay seo copywriting services

  104. Alvinhub says:

    You actually expressed it effectively!
    personal statement college essay essay writer writer services

  105. You said that superbly.
    no prescription pharmacies pharmacies near me canadian pharmacy meds

  106. Incredible tons of awesome tips!
    fda approved canadian online pharmacies canadian cialis modafinil online pharmacy

  107. Alvinhub says:

    Thank you! Good stuff.
    custom essays online how to write a essay proposal help writing a book

  108. Alvinhub says:

    Useful forum posts. Regards.
    college supplemental essays best college admission essay me as a writer essay

  109. Many thanks, Quite a lot of tips!
    pharmacy online pharmacy prices compare top rated canadian pharmacies online

  110. Wow quite a lot of superb material!
    prescription drug assistance online pharmacies of canada prescription drug assistance

  111. Juido says:

    About the Brand: Rimmel London is a British cosmetics brand that brings you innovative range of makeup products. From your make-up essentials to experimental on trend colours, Rimmel London has something for everyone and every occasion. The brand is constantly innovating to re-shape convention, create new looks, to give you the tools to explore new versions of your look. All Rimmel products are safe and have been developed, manufactured and packaged in compliance with the laws, regulations and guidelines that are applicable in each country in which they are sold. 100% Secure Checkout Rimmel Ultimate Kohl Kajal Eye Pencil Shop-224, level-2, Finlay Square, CDA Avenue,Chattogram ULTIMATE KOHL KAJAL Black obsidian is an essential makeup tool that no girl should be without. Scandaleyes Kohl Kajal Liner adds extra drama to eyes, with no running, no smudging. What a great little present for your bff, your sister or your mum! Rimmel London is an inner confidence that how we look is always cool, irreverent, never predictable and always evolving. Rimmel is not perfection or intimidating, it is like London : young, urban, eclectic, edgy. It is expression with no rules, it is real, it is accessible. GET THE LONDON LOOK. https://i-chooselove.com/community/profile/morabarbee67224/ This article contains affiliate links, we may receive a commission on any sales we generate from it. Learn more Product size: 15g This article contains affiliate links, we may receive a commission on any sales we generate from it. Learn more ВЈ11.99 each ВЈ39.97 per 100g INGREDIENTSINGREDIENTS : CAPRYLIC CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDE, SILICA, ISONONYL ISONONANOATE, CERA MICROCRISTALLINA (MICROCRYSTALLINE WAX, CIRE MICROCRYSTALLINE), MICA, ISODODECANE, PARAFFIN, POLYBUTENE, POLYETHYLENE, BIS-DIGLYCERYL POLYACYLADIPATE-2, GLYCOL MONTANATE, SYNTHETIC WAX (CIRE SYNTHETIQUE), ETHYLHEXYL PALMITATE, PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUM (MINERAL OIL, HUILE MINERALE), 3-O-ETHYL ASCORBIC ACID, PANTHENOL, TOCOPHERYL ACETATE, BIS-DIGLYCERYL POLYACYLADIPATE-1, ISOPROPYL MYRISTATE, PETROLATUM , BHT, PROPYLPARABEN, PARFUM (FRAGRANCE), CI 77891 (TITANIUM DIOXIDE), CI 77491 (IRON OXIDES), CI 77492 (IRON OXIDES), CI 77499 (IRON OXIDES).

  112. Mavisstsl says:

    meet older women for free
    top dating sites in usa
    free dating net

  113. Alvinhub says:

    Great facts. With thanks.
    community service essays https://dissertationwritingtops.com/ best content writing websites

  114. Alvinhub says:

    You said it perfectly.!
    how to write application essay fast essay writing service novel writing help

  115. Alvinhub says:

    Thank you. Lots of stuff.
    how to write a conclusion for a college essay https://service-essay.com/ speech writing service

  116. Nicely put. Thanks!
    buying drugs canada canada pharmacy online orders canada pharmacy no prescription

  117. Thank you. A lot of data.
    reputable canadian mail order pharmacies online pharmacy without scripts canadianpharmacy

  118. purchase sildenafil generic cenforce 100mg oral order generic cenforce

  119. Alvinhub says:

    Lovely content, Appreciate it.
    essay writing formats essays writing services grant writing services

  120. Alvinhub says:

    Nicely put. Regards.
    writing essay scholarships essay how to write academic writing service