What drives unethical behaviour in Board Members and Executives

What drives unethical behaviour in Board Members and Executives

Sometimes I get puzzled when I see organisations spending a lot of money training Non- Executive Directors and Executives Directors specifically targeting to reduce unethical conduct.  I guess the belief in those championing such training is that these senior executives are involved in unethical behaviour because they do not know what is right and wrong. Most of the corporate governance scandals you see every day are committed by people who are very educated and knowledgeable. While training will help with procedural issues it does not stop thieves in your Board from stealing. It is their nature. They will continue stealing despite all the money you are spending on training.

So where is the problem and how can it be addressed? The problem is in the personality of the individuals that are selected to lead organisations and Boards. If you get the wrong personality into your organisation do not expect them to change. Personality is a permanent disposition that is reflected in how the individual behaves across situations. Personality is an individual’s stable and consistent thoughts and behaviour across different situations (Walumbwa & Schaubroeck, 2009).  Research has shown that “People with certain personality traits are more likely to behave ethically or unethically” (Greenbaum, Hill, Mawritz, & Quade, 2014). With the above finding above, let us look at the different personality types and how they relate to ethical behaviour.

Let us look at the big five personality traits and how they influence ethical behaviour.  Conscientiousness is the first one; it is defined as “a broad dimension of personality that encompasses a person’s predisposition to control their behaviour in socially acceptable ways (Roberts, Jackson, Fayard, Edmonds, & Meints, 2009). It reflects how organised someone is. People that are high on conscientious are always reliable and get the job done according to agreed plans. The people low on conscientiousness are always late and rarely get things done according to agreed plans. According to research, people high on conscientiousness tend to be “self-disciplined, think before they act, are goal-directed and follow socially prescribed rules and norms” (Roberts et al, 2009). Bratton & Strittmatter (
2013) discovered that Conscientiousness correlates negatively with dishonesty and cheating. From the above research, you can already see how important this personality dimension is at any role within the organisation.

The second personality dimension is Agreeableness and it corresponds to how easy going an individual is. People high on agreeableness get along with everyone. Those low on agreeableness tend to argue a lot even for no apparent reason. In contrast, people low on agreeableness “show lack of concern for others, (are) tense, irritable, and rebellious, thus they tend to display unethical behaviour” (Walumbwa & Schaubroeck, 2009).

The third of the big five personality traits is Extroversion. This trait reflects in highly social people who are outgoing and very comfortable interacting with people – even strangers.  Currently, there is no conclusive evidence linking extraversion to unethical behaviour.

The fourth personality trait is Openness to experience. People high on this trait are open-minded.  They are likely to welcome new ideas and new ways of doing things. An individual low on this trait is adverse to new ideas and new ways of doing ways. They stick to the traditional ways of doing things: the ways familiar to themselves even if such ways are no longer adding value. So far no positive relationship has been found between openness to experience and unethical behaviour.

The fifth personality trait is called Neuroticism. This trait reflects how emotionally volatile someone is. Individuals who are highly neurotic are prone toward frequent changes in mood. They experience negative affect (bad feelings) most of the time. In the majority of the studies neuroticism has been found to be the significant predictor of unethical behaviour (e.g., Camps et al., 2016; Walumbwa & Schaubroeck, 2009). Individuals low on neuroticism “value morality, loyalty, and obedience to norms. They have a sense of direction and are altruistic and emphatic” (Karim et al., 2009).  Such people are more rational in their actions and less likely to resort to unethical behaviour in pursuit of their goals.

Given the above the above findings, it is very clear that in order to deal with unethical behaviour in organisations the “powers that be” need to make sure that anyone joining their organisation in whatever capacity has the right personality in line with company values. It is a waste of money to try and train people who have defective personalities to behave well.

Since most companies ignore personality when hiring, they incur huge costs when such people behave unethically. Look around and you will notice that those who are unethical continue to do so regardless of the environment or organisation they work for.

Memory Nguwi. Memory Nguwi is an Occupational Psychologist, Data Scientist, Speaker, & Managing Consultant- Industrial Psychology Consultants (Pvt) Ltd a management and human resources consulting firm. He is the president of the Zimbabwe Psychology Association. He hosts a radio program HR Perspective every Thursday at 1900hrs on Capitalk 100.4FMhttps://www.linkedin.com/in/memorynguwi/ Phone 481946-48/481950/2900276/2900966  or email: mnguwi@ipcconsultants.com  or visit our website at www.ipcconsultants.com

225 Responses

  1. Uspgwu says:

    cefuroxime 250mg uk – generic cialis tadalafil 5mg sale

  2. Imzaxl says:

    oral ceftin 500mg – methocarbamol 500mg oral tadalafil 20mg cheap

  3. Wiijkz says:

    ampicillin generic – buy ampicillin female cialis cvs

  4. Grwltf says:

    oral acillin – ampicillin 500mg pill oral tadalafil 5mg

  5. Hkrbdd says:

    amoxil 250mg usa – amoxicillin canada vardenafil order online

  6. Fqkrow says:

    amoxicillin 250mg generic – purchase vardenafil online purchase levitra generic

  7. Cowlyw says:

    ivermectin 8 mg – levitra 10mg tablet purchase levitra without prescription

  8. Oegkfs says:

    ivermectin 12 – ivermectin 6mg over the counter levitra 20mg uk

  9. Xxnoxd says:

    doxycycline oral – doxycycline 100mg price tadalafil 20mg oral

  10. Nnljbx says:

    purchase doxycycline generic – buy clomiphene pill buy cialis 40mg pill

  11. Puycjf says:

    buy tadalafil 5mg for sale – cheap cialis order provigil pill

  12. Bgfobx says:

    tadalafil 20mg oral – best online pharmacy in canada purchase modafinil

  13. Xagldd says:

    deltasone us – ed pills that work quickly accutane 10mg usa

  14. Viwlbj says:

    order generic deltasone 20mg – accutane 40mg cheap accutane 20mg uk

  15. Vzxtmh says:

    amoxicillin 250mg pill – amoxil pills viagra for sale online

  16. Idwpaq says:

    buy amoxicillin 250mg generic – viagra 100mg pills for sale viagra generic

  17. Dpfquw says:

    prednisolone 20mg cost – neurontin 100mg pills sildenafil 50mg oral

  18. Npgkwq says:

    order prednisolone 10mg generic – buy prednisolone tablets viagra 150mg sale

  19. Ipdzkr says:

    lasix 40mg brand – brand doxycycline 200mg stromectol ivermectin 3 mg

  20. Escmii says:

    order furosemide online – ivermectin 12mg pills ivermectin 200mg

  21. Malrms says:

    order plaquenil 400mg without prescription – oral baricitinib 4mg baricitinib 4mg ca

  22. Faogsb says:

    hydroxychloroquine 200mg over the counter – order generic baricitinib 4mg buy generic baricitinib 2mg

  23. Gwwacs says:

    order glucophage 500mg pills – glucophage online order oral amlodipine 10mg

  24. Ntzasu says:

    vardenafil order online – generic medrol online order clomiphene 100mg generic

  25. Wigctx says:

    buy vardenafil 20mg online – medrol buy online purchase clomid generic

  26. Nkknpk says:

    ventolin inhalator for sale online – sports gambling priligy oral

  27. Fvnfnd says:

    order generic ventolin 4mg – real money slots order priligy 30mg generic

  28. Chnkzd says:

    synthroid cost – order synthroid 100mcg online plaquenil medication

  29. Hrjqao says:

    cheap synthroid generic – oral aristocort 4mg hydroxychloroquine brand

  30. Kxefnv says:

    cheap cialis tablets – order generic tadalafil sildenafil 50mg tablets

  31. Kbpmkw says:

    tadalafil 20mg canada – sildenafil 150mg for sale generic sildenafil 100mg

  32. Zpbjow says:

    buy deltasone 5mg without prescription – predisone with no presciption amoxicillin cheap

  33. Mcbomi says:

    order prednisone 5mg online cheap – purchase amoxil online cheap order amoxicillin 250mg pills

  34. Ektfhv says:

    order diltiazem generic – gabapentin 800mg drug gabapentin 100mg price

  35. Hcjskh says:

    buy diltiazem pills – purchase zithromax generic buy generic neurontin

  36. Dafaht says:

    lasix ca – zovirax 800mg tablet purchase doxycycline online

  37. Reteyf says:

    buy generic lasix 100mg – generic doxycycline 200mg doxycycline 200mg drug

  38. Vxtknj says:

    order cenforce without prescription – domperidone tablet order motilium pills

  39. Kktjbx says:

    cheap cenforce – order cenforce for sale cost domperidone 10mg

  40. Khjydq says:

    oral sildenafil 100mg – cialis 10mg over the counter cialis 10mg pills

  41. Oucoxi says:

    order sildenafil 50mg pill – cialis 5mg price oral cialis 10mg

  42. Dkphhb says:

    modafinil online order – prednisone price budesonide drug

  43. Pindmh says:

    provigil 100mg generic – non prescription erection pills buy rhinocort generic

  44. Jgubws says:

    buy accutane 20mg generic – amoxicillin 500mg without prescription tetracycline 250mg brand

  45. Mxeyyb says:

    order isotretinoin pills – amoxil 500mg price order tetracycline for sale

  46. Kzlycp says:

    cyclobenzaprine canada – toradol without prescription propranolol cost

  47. Hksxkk says:

    flexeril online – inderal 10mg oral order inderal generic

  48. Hqprkp says:

    clopidogrel cost – order plavix sale reglan 10mg without prescription

  49. Nsnoqc says:

    order clopidogrel pills – metoclopramide over the counter metoclopramide over the counter

  50. Gctmnp says:

    cozaar tablet – cost topiramate 200mg phenergan order online

  51. Pmfymy says:

    cozaar without prescription – buy cozaar 25mg online cheap promethazine order online

  52. Pxnyij says:

    levofloxacin generic – dutasteride sale order tadalafil 5mg pills

  53. Wiozss says:

    order levofloxacin online cheap – tadalafil medication order generic tadalafil 10mg

  54. Izikmi says:

    cheap tadalafil 20mg – tadalafil pills tamsulosin sale

  55. Pxoqat says:

    oral tadalafil 5mg – brand meloxicam 7.5mg flomax us

  56. Iexbex says:

    zofran pills – simvastatin 10mg usa valtrex 500mg sale

  57. Bcddzf says:

    order zofran 8mg sale – ondansetron 4mg us order valacyclovir 500mg for sale

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.